Uncategorized

Reviews and AI Search Visibility: Where the FTC and UK Fake-Review Rules Draw the Line

If review profiles help a brand appear in AI answers, some teams will be tempted to manufacture them. A May 2026 Seer Interactive study of 804,491 AI responses found a large gap between brands with and without a Trustpilot profile, but both the US and the UK ban fake and misleading reviews. GEO, short for Generative Engine Optimization, has to work inside those rules.

Key Takeaways
  • Seer Interactive reported a median citation rate of 1% for brands without a verified Trustpilot profile and 53.5% for brands with a minimal one. The firm calls this a correlation.
  • The FTC’s rule, announced August 14, 2024, bans fake reviews, including AI-generated ones, and reviews bought for a particular sentiment.
  • In the UK, the DMCC Act ban took effect on April 6, 2025, with fines of up to 10% of annual global turnover.
  • Marketing and SEO agencies that commission fake reviews for a client are in scope in the UK.

What the evidence shows

Seer Interactive’s study, published May 14, 2026, analyzed 804,491 responses from ChatGPT, Google AI Mode, Gemini and Perplexity. It covered 1,926 brands, 8 verticals and 15,783 prompts, with data collected mainly in March 2026. It reported a median citation rate of 1% for brands with no verified Trustpilot profile and 53.5% for brands with a minimal profile.

Seer describes the results as correlations and notes that marketing spend and audience size may play a part. The study centers on Trustpilot, and the article links to a Trustpilot white paper, so read it as vendor-adjacent evidence.

The implication is that real, visible customer feedback probably helps. It does not show that more reviews cause more citations, and it says nothing about reviews that are fake.

The US rule

The FTC announced its final rule on consumer reviews and testimonials on August 14, 2024, by a 5-0 vote. It prohibits fake reviews, explicitly including AI-generated ones, and reviews from people who never used the product. It also bans offering compensation conditioned on a positive or negative sentiment, and using baseless threats to remove negative reviews.

The rule covers undisclosed insider reviews and company-controlled sites posing as independent review sources. The FTC says it can seek civil penalties against knowing violators. Secondary sources date the rule’s effect to October 21, 2024.

For a GEO plan, the practical meaning is simple: do not generate, buy or gate reviews to influence what AI engines read about you.

The UK rule

CMS law firm summarizes the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers (DMCC) Act as banning the submission or commissioning of fake reviews and the misleading publication of review information, such as suppressing negative reviews or cherry-picking positive ones. The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) published its guidance, CMA208, on April 4, 2025. The ban took effect two days later.

CMS reports that fines can reach 10% of annual global turnover and that the CMA can impose them without going to court. Incentivised reviews are allowed only if genuine and prominently labelled. Law firm Herbert Smith Freehills Kramer reported that the CMA opened its first formal fake-review investigations in March 2026.

PracticeUS (FTC rule)UK (DMCC Act)
Fake or AI-generated reviewsBannedBanned, including commissioning them
Rewards for a particular ratingBannedBanned; incentives must be genuine and labelled
Hiding negative reviewsBaseless threats bannedSuppression and cherry-picking banned
Agencies acting for a clientCovered where they create or disseminateExplicitly covered when commissioning

A compliant review program

The steps below are our recommendation, not legal advice. Check them with counsel for your sector.

  1. Ask every customer for feedback, not only the ones likely to be happy.
  2. Publish the reviews you receive, positive and negative, and respond to them.
  3. Label any incentive clearly, and never tie a reward to a rating.
  4. Write contracts with agencies that prohibit fake or commissioned reviews.
  5. Track whether review-site and brand mentions rise in AI answers, using our guide to measuring AI search visibility.

Related reading: how B2B buyers use AI shortlists and what the FTC and ASA say about AI content.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do reviews help a business appear in AI answers?

Seer Interactive’s 2026 study of 804,491 responses found a strong correlation between having a Trustpilot profile and being cited. It did not prove causation.

Are AI-generated reviews illegal?

In the US, the FTC rule bans fake reviews, explicitly including AI-generated ones. In the UK, the DMCC Act bans submitting or commissioning fake reviews.

Can a business offer a discount in exchange for a review?

Not in exchange for a particular rating. In the UK, incentivised reviews must be genuine and clearly labelled. In the US, rewards conditioned on sentiment are banned.

Visibility that depends on shortcuts can turn into a liability. At Grow with Hafsa we help US and UK businesses build review and citation strategies that hold up to regulators and to AI engines, as part of our AI marketing and performance marketing services.